Etsy's arts and crafts marketplace on laptop
Arts and crafts remain in demand with consumers despite cost-of-living pressures
  • Relief as shares stage recovery rally
  • Q1 revenues and earnings beat 'The Street'
  • Toned down Q2 growth still sees 11% increase year-on-year

Investors might well have been nervous ahead of latest earnings from arts and crafts consumer platform Etsy (ETSY:NASDAQ). These were the first quarterly figures since a report (17 Feb) by short seller Citron Research that alleged the company is ‘one of the largest counterfeiting platforms in the world.’

Effectively being accused of flogging hooky goods on a scale that would make Del Boy and Rodders blush had hung over the share price in the weeks since, losing nearly 24%.

But latest earnings gave the stock a lift that will be welcomed by investor fans, and the shares are set to open later today up 3%, according to pre-market data, putting the stock back into three-digits at $101.90.

Brooklyn-based Etsy reported first-quarter earnings and revenue overnight that topped analyst estimates, even if the revenue outlook came in below expectations. The e-commerce marketplace reported earnings of $0.53 for the quarter ending 31 March, down 12% from a year earlier but above the $0.51 anticipated by analysts.

GROWTH GUIDANCE TONED DOWN

Revenue up 11% at $640.9 million also beat ‘The Street’, nearly 3.5% better.

Gross merchandise sales, or the dollar value of items sold across all Etsy marketplaces, rose 4.6% to $3.1 billion. That topped Wall Street estimates of $3.06 billion.

Craftswoman making jewellery

That said, the company believes analyst expectations for second quarter growth have got a bit ahead of themselves. Q2 sales are now seen at around $615 million, at the midpoint of management’s outlook, below estimates of $627 million.

That would still imply almost 11% growth year-on-year in Q2.

Analysts see the share price recovery continuing, with the average target pitched for the stock at $129, about 30% up from current levels. Of the 29 analyst that follow the stock, 16 are telling clients to buy versus two sellers, according to Koyfin data.

Find out how to deal online from £1.50 in a SIPP, ISA or Dealing account. AJ Bell logo

Issue Date: 04 May 2023